Shopping for Car Insurance

For years I knew that one day my Dad would kick me off the car insurance. That day has come, and I have been doing diligent shopping, quality, and price comparisons to help me make a decision.


The first thing that most people look at when shopping for insurance is the price. Obviously that is a major factor, and you should compare several companies to find the best price.

From commercials, we know about companies like Geico, Aflac, AllState, State Farm, e-surance, and a handful of others. Some claim to save you “15% or more” with one call. Others will compare your rate with other companies.

There is no right or wrong way to do this. You can call in and get a quote or you can do it yourself online. Either method has its own advantages and disadvantages regarding time, speed, and discounts.

One caution, however, is your credit. One of the major factors in determining your rate is your credit score. To get your score, some companies use a ‘soft hit,’ which does not impact your credit report, and some use a ‘hard hit,’ which impacts your report and can lower your score. If you get a lot of quotes, ask about how they pull your credit first.


All insurance companies are not equal. If you read customer satisfaction surveys and check Consumer’s Report, you will find that some of the older, high service companies like Liberty Mutual and All State score higher than the low price focused sites.

Make sure that your plan gives you extensive coverage. I have only taken quotes for low deductible (about $250), high coverage plans that include uninsured motorist, medical, and comprehensive vehicle coverage.

Some companies are able to offer a lower rate because they do not offer as extensive coverage. You have to decide for yourself which is more important, but I would rather err on the side of having better coverage.

Customer Service

If you have ever had to file a claim, you know it can be a miserable process. Dealing with approved shops, quotes, rental cars, repair schedules, surveys, deductibles, and customer service representatives can be a nightmare.

Again, read online customer satisfaction reports and certain trends emerge. You will easily find which companies have good service and coverage and which will leave you angry, upset, or frustrated.

Any Advice?

I have not made the final choice yet, but two companies are the frontrunners. What companies have you been happy with? Which left you with a bad experience? Any other tips that I missed? Please give your thoughts in the comments.

Photo by Dospaz.

12 thoughts on “Shopping for Car Insurance”

  1. Good advice! Unfortunately, some of those intangibles are subjective because you do not intend to have an accident. That is one of the reasons you can tolerate a higher deductible.

    1. I completely agree. You can’t put a dollar value on certain parts of the package, like customer service, so you have to decide what is worth the price to you. There is no one-size-fits-all solution.

  2. Definitely. I know what insurance cost as a 16 year old boy. I feel like it is cheap now over 25. Driving safely is the best defense and safety tip on the road.

  3. Farmers is good if you have issues, but they are overpriced in my opinion. Allstate keeps increasing premiums for no apparent reason. Heard nothing but bad press about state farm (I haven’t used them personally though).

    thumbs up for both Geico and progressive.

    1. I checked into that. There is a discount for doing so, but I might be able to get a cheaper policy somewhere else that makes up more than the difference. Thanks for the comment.

  4. Great advice to anyone. I have been paying for my insurance since I was 16, so I know exactly what they charge for the extra risk.

    Driving safe is worth more than insurance, it can keep you safe and alive. I have seen and experienced injuries from car accidents and I know what it can do to your life.

  5. I really love Progressive. I used to shop around frequently when it was time to renew, and I have kinda gotten away from doing that the last few years. Progressive consistently offered lower rates than the competition (at least here in Michigan), and everything can be renewed, and claims can be made, online.

    They also offer a new discount program for people that dont mind installing a chip under their hood to measure speeds and distances driven.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top